The Allen Thomas Group Independent Insurance Agency

Call Now or Get A Quote

Restaurant Insurance in New York

Get A New York Restaurant Insurance Quote Today

It Just Takes A Few Clicks

Or Give Us A Call At (440) 826-3676

food contamination insurance in New York

Understanding Restaurant Insurance in New York

food liability insurance in New York

As a restaurant owner in New York, you know the key ingredients for success – incredible food, outstanding service, and an ambiance that keeps ’em coming back for more.

But have you considered one crucial ingredient that can make or break your business? Insurance.

Without the right restaurant insurance in New York, one unexpected incident could leave a sour taste that spoils everything you’ve worked for.

At The Allen Thomas Group, we are a top-rated insurance agency that understands the unique risks restaurants face every day, from hungry customers to wet floors to spoiled ingredients.

That’s why we’ve cooked up comprehensive commercial insurance solutions that cover your business insurance needs to protect your business and keep it running smoothly.  

So what are you waiting for?

Get a quote for your small business!

Table of Contents

How much does restaurant insurance in New York cost?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to how much restaurant insurance costs in New York. The price can vary significantly depending on several factors:

  • Location: Restaurants in high-traffic areas or with higher crime rates may pay more for insurance.
  • Type of Cuisine: Fine dining establishments typically have higher insurance costs compared to casual cafes due to the value of equipment and potential for foodborne illness claims.
  • Alcohol Service: Restaurants serving alcohol require liquor liability insurance, which adds to the overall cost.
  • Delivery Services: Delivery operations require commercial auto insurance, impacting the premium.
  • Size and Revenue: Larger restaurants with higher revenue tend to have higher insurance costs.
  • Claims History: Restaurants with a history of claims will likely pay more for insurance.

Business insurance for restaurants in New York can range from $1,750 to $5,000 per year, with an average around $3,000.

Getting The Right Coverage Mix

Why Restaurant Insurance in New York is Crucial?

Protect against costly lawsuits
According to the National Restaurant Association, the average cost of a slip-and-fall claim for a restaurant is around $20,000. With general liability insurance, restaurants can protect themselves against such costly lawsuits arising from customer injuries or accidents on their premises.

Comply with state regulations
In New York, workers’ compensation insurance and liquor liability insurance (if serving alcohol) are mandatory. Failure to carry these coverages can result in hefty fines and penalties. For instance, the maximum fine for not having workers’ compensation insurance in New York is $2,000 for every 10-day period of non-compliance.

Safeguard against foodborne illnesses
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimates that foodborne illnesses cost the United States over $55 billion annually. With general liability and product liability insurance, restaurants can protect themselves from lawsuits and expenses resulting from foodborne illness outbreaks.

Recover from disasters and business interruptions
According to the National Restaurant Association, 40% of restaurants fail to reopen after a disaster. Business interruption insurance can help restaurants recover financially and continue operations after events like fires, natural disasters, or forced closures by health departments.

Protect against alcohol-related incidents
In New York, the Dram Shop Law holds establishments liable for serving alcohol to visibly intoxicated patrons. Liquor liability insurance can cover legal fees, settlements, and judgments arising from such incidents, which can be costly for restaurants without proper insurance protection.

By having the right restaurant business insurance options, business owners in New York can mitigate the financial risks associated with lawsuits, comply with state regulations, and better protect your business and income from various perils, ensuring long-term sustainability.

Types of New York Business Insurance Coverage

General liability insurance covers your restaurant from third-party claims of bodily injury, property damage, or advertising injuries that occur on your premises or as a result of your operations. 

A crucial part of the best restaurant insurance package, this insurance provides coverage for your business in case a customer slips and falls, suffers from food poisoning, or if your advertising inadvertently causes harm to someone else’s reputation or intellectual property.

This insurance helps pay for damages.

General Liability Insurance: $500 – $2,500 annually

Workers’ comp insurance is a legal requirement in most states. Even New York requires businesses with employees to have workers compensation coverage for restaurant.

This insurance offers financial protection in the case of lost wages. Insurance pays for medical expenses for workers who sustain job-related injuries or illnesses. 

It also protects your restaurant from lawsuits filed by injured employees, ensuring compliance with state laws and regulations.

$600 – $10,000 annually (highly dependent on payroll size and job risk)

You need business property insurance to protect your business and its physical assets, including the building, furniture, equipment, and signage.

It covers damage caused by various perils, such as:

  • Fire
  • Theft
  • Vandalism
  • Weather events (depending on policy)

If a fire breaks out in your kitchen and damages ovens, refrigerators, and countertops, your business may benefit from commercial property insurance.

Many restaurants have benefited from this policy that can pay for repairs or replacements and protect your small business.

If your restaurant in New York state operates a delivery service or has vehicles used for business purposes, commercial auto insurance is necessary. 

This coverage protects your vehicles in the event of accidents, theft, and vandalism, as well as provides liability coverage for bodily injury or property damage caused by your drivers while operating the vehicles for business purposes.

If your restaurant serves alcoholic beverages, liquor liability insurance is crucial.

This insurance for restaurants protects you from claims arising from incidents involving intoxicated patrons, such as fights, property damage, or accidents caused by overserved customers.

Liquor liability insurance is often required by state and local authorities as a condition for obtaining a liquor license.

Liquor Liability Insurance: $300 – $3,000 annually (can vary significantly depending on liquor sales volume)

This is not a standalone policy but often an add-on coverage to your commercial property insurance or BOP specifically for perishable inventory. It covers:

  • Spoilage of food due to power outages or equipment breakdown
  • Costs associated with a foodborne illness outbreak, including:
    • Medical expenses for sick customers
    • Product recall
    • Lost business income due to closure

Also known as errors and omissions insurance, business liability insurance offers protection for your restaurant from lawsuits alleging negligence that leads to customer injuries or illnesses.

Business owners must take liability coverage, including professional liability insurance, to secure their restaurant from claims of negligence.

For example, a customer gets sick from undercooked food at your restaurant and sues you for negligence.

Liability insurance can help cover your legal defense costs.

In today’s digital age, restaurants are increasingly reliant on technology for operations, such as point-of-sale systems, online ordering, and customer data management.

Cyber insurance helps protect your business from the financial and legal consequences of data breaches, cyber-attacks, and other cyber-related incidents, which can be costly and damaging to your reputation.

A BOP is a bundled policy combining essential coverages for businesses like restaurants, including:

  • General Liability Insurance 
  • Commercial Property Insurance 
  • Business Interruption Insurance 

BOP policies are often more affordable than purchasing each coverage separately. 

Umbrella insurance is an extra layer of protection in the event a lawsuit exceeds the limits of your New York restaurant insurance policy.

liquor liability insurance in New York
Stress-free Solutions

Is a certificate of insurance necessary for restaurant business in New York 

affordable New York restaurant insurance quote

In New York, a certificate of insurance is necessary to prove that your comprehensive restaurant insurance needs are fulfilled. Here’s a breakdown:

Liquor Liability: If your restaurant serves alcohol, you will need liquor liability insurance as part of your restaurant insurance program. As part of obtaining a liquor license, the state will likely require you to provide a certificate of insurance showing you have the required amount of liquor liability coverage.

Landlord Requirements: Some landlords may require tenants, including restaurants, to carry certain types of insurance, such as general liability insurance. They might ask you to provide a certificate of insurance as proof of coverage.

Other Situations: While not universally required, a certificate of insurance might be requested in other situations. For example, if you participate in a special event or use a shared kitchen space, they might require proof of insurance.

Insurance Solutions Customized For You

Yes, It's Really That Easy

We know how frustrating and complex the process of finding the right restaurant insurance can be and how it affects your peace of mind when you don’t have the right coverage. Let us help craft a policy that works for you.

Step 1: Assess

Tell us about your specific needs and we will find the right policy for you.

Step 2: Review

Review the results of our search.

Step 3: Service

We will walk you through your new policy step by step.

Our happy customers
We’ve helped NY Restaurant Clients Just Like You

Our Carrier Partners

WE HAVE PERSONAL CONTACTS WITH THESE TRUSTED A-RATED INSURANCE COMPANIES

That allows us to find the best rates for your restaurant

Get A Business Insurance Quote Online for New York based Restaurant Today 

Running a restaurant in New York isn’t just about creating incredible dishes – it’s about following a recipe book of rules and regulations to keep your customers and employees safe. 

With a tailored insurance program from The Allen Thomas Group, you can focus on running your business with the peace of mind that comes from being protected and compliant. 

At The Allen Thomas Group, we’ve spent over 20 years tailoring the right insurance solutions for food and beverage businesses across New York. 

We know how insurance helps minimize the threat posed to your business. We can customize policies to help you understand how insurance can help protect and run a small business, according to the New York law.

Because at The Allen Thomas Group, we believe every restaurant deserves to serve its customers security and success, right alongside its signature dishes. Our affordable policies ensure you don’t have to spend too much insurance dollars.

 Every business deserves the security of the best insurance coverage. The Allen Thomas Group understands your business needs and can help you understand insurance information and get the best options from top insurance carriers.

Start a quote now. It’s easy to get a free quote at The Allen Thomas Group. 

Call us today at  440-826-3676, and one of our insurance agents will get started on whipping up a specific insurance program to protect your entrepreneurial vision. It’s the perfect pairing for your culinary ambitions.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

Get More Insights On Making The Right Insurance Decision For Your Restaurant 

EPL insurance protects your restaurant from claims made by employees alleging wrongful employment practices, such as discrimination, harassment, wrongful termination, or retaliation. 

This type of business coverage can help cover legal fees, settlements, and judgments related to these claims, which can be costly and time-consuming to defend against.

For New York restaurants, business interruption insurance acts like a financial safety net if your business is forced to close due to an eventuality.

This type of insurance covers lost income from dine-in, takeout, catering, and events during closure due to fire, theft, health scares, or other insured situations.

Such business insurance in New York reimburses you for the lost revenue you would have made during that time.

Eleven Madison Park: One of the most acclaimed fine dining establishments, offering a seasonal tasting menu.

Le Bernardin: Michelin-starred French seafood cuisine with seasonal ingredients.

Per Se: Michelin-starred restaurant by Chef Thomas Keller, featuring a luxurious tasting menu of modern American cuisine.

Katz’s Delicatessen: Iconic New York institution famous for its massive pastrami sandwiches and Jewish deli fare.

Peter Luger Steak House: New York steakhouse staple known for dry-aged cuts of beef and an old-school atmosphere.

The Modern: Michelin-starred restaurant offering stunning views of the Museum of Modern Art, alongside innovative American cuisine.

Jean-Georges: Restaurant by celebrity chef Jean-Georges Vongerichten serving French cuisine with Asian accents.

Rao’s: Tiny Harlem restaurant famous for its celebrity clientele and traditional Italian cuisine.

Balthazar: New York institution, a French bistro with a lively atmosphere and a menu of classic dishes.

Pastis: Popular bistro in the Meatpacking District offering French comfort food and a lively atmosphere.

Nobu: World-renowned chain known for Japanese cuisine with a Peruvian influence (sushi, sashimi, etc.).

Eataly: Giant Italian marketplace housing numerous restaurants serving pizza, pasta, seafood, meats, and more.

Shake Shack: Popular burger chain originated in New York City, known for juicy burgers, crinkle-cut fries, and frozen custard.

Dominique Ansel Bakery: Bakery famous for its Cronut, a croissant-doughnut hybrid.

Halal Guys: Popular street food vendor known for its chicken and rice platters with yellow rice, white sauce, and hot sauce.

 

New York State Department of Financial Services (DFS): https://www.dfs.ny.gov/

Small Business Administration (SBA): https://www.sba.gov/

New York State Workers’ Compensation Board (WCB): https://www.wcb.ny.gov/

National Restaurant Association ServSafe Manager Certification: https://restaurant.org/

Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) https://www.osha.gov/

 

New York Cities We Serve

Albany

Amherst

Amsterdam

Arcadia

Auburn

Aurora

Baldwin

Batavia

Bay Shore

Beacon

Bedford

Beekman

Bellmore

Bethlehem

Bethpage

Binghamton

Blooming Grove

Brentwood

Brighton

Brookhaven

Brooklyn

Brunswick

Buffalo

Carmel

Centereach

Central Islip

Cheektowaga

Chili

Cicero

Clarence

Clarkstown

Clay

Clifton Park

Cohoes

Commack

Copiague

Coram

Cornwall

Cortland

Cortlandt

Deer Park

Depew

De Witt

Dix Hills

Eastchester

East Fishkill

East Greenbush

East Islip

East Massapequa

East Meadow

East Northport

East Patchogue

Eggertsville

Elmira

Elmont

Endicott

Evans

Fallsburg

Farmington

Farmingville

Floral Park

Fort Drum

Franklin Square

Freeport

Garden City

Gates

Geddes

Geneva

German Flatts

Glen Cove

Glens Falls

Glenville

Gloversville

Grand Island

Greece

Greenburgh

Greenlawn

Guilderland

Halfmoon

Hampton Bays

Harrison

Hauppauge

Hempstead

Henrietta

Hicksville

Highlands

Holbrook

Holtsville

Huntington

Huntington Station

Hyde Park

Irondequoit

Islip

Ithaca

Jamestown

Jericho

Johnson City

Kenmore

Kent

Kingsbury

Kings Park

Kingston

Kiryas Joel

Lackawanna

La Grange

Lake Ronkonkoma

Le Ray

Levittown

Lewisboro

Lindenhurst

Lockport

Long Beach

Lynbrook

Lysander

Malta

Mamaroneck

Manhattan

Manorville

Massapequa

Massapequa Park

Mastic

Mastic Beach

Medford

Melville

Merrick

Middletown

Milton

Mineola

Monsey

Moreau

Mount Pleasant

Mount Vernon

Nanuet

Nesconset

Newburgh

New Cassel

New Castle

New City

New Rochelle

New Windsor

New York City

Niagara Falls

Niskayuna

North Amityville

North Babylon

North Bay Shore

North Bellmore

North Castle

North Greenbush

North Hempstead

North Massapequa

North Merrick

North New Hyde Park

North Tonawanda

North Valley Stream

Oceanside

Ogden

Olean

Oneonta

Onondaga

Orangetown

Ossining

Oswego

Oyster Bay

Palm Tree

Parma

Patchogue

Pearl River

Peekskill

Penfield

Perinton

Plainview

Plattsburgh

Pomfret

Port Chester

Port Washington

Poughkeepsie

Queens

Queensbury

Ramapo

Ridge

Riverhead

Rochester

Rockville Centre

Rocky Point

Rome

Ronkonkoma

Roosevelt

Rotterdam

Rye

Salina

Salisbury

Saratoga Springs

Sayville

Scarsdale

Schenectady

Schodack

Seaford

Selden

Setauket-East Setauket

Shawangunk

Shirley

Smithtown

Somers

Southeast

South Farmingdale

Southold

Spring Valley

St. James

Staten Island

Stony Brook

Stony Point

Sullivan

Sweden

Syosset

Syracuse

Terryville

The Bronx

Thompson

Tonawanda

Troy

Ulster

Union

Uniondale

Utica

Valley Stream

Van Buren

Vestal

Wallkill

Wantagh

Wappinger

Watertown

Wawarsing

West Babylon

Westbury

West Hempstead

West Islip

West Seneca

Wheatfield

White Plains

Whitestown

Wilton

Woodmere

Yonkers

Yorktown